Introduction:
Has someone ever tried to tarnish your reputation? Or perhaps you have been accused of defamation and want to understand your rights. Defamation law can be complex, but its principles, when broken down, are straightforward. This guide walks you through the basics of defamation and how it operates in Victoria. The statute that governs defamation in Victoria is the Defamation Act 2005 (Vic), however legislation is uniform across all states and territories.
Limitation of Actions:
Before starting proceedings, understand that timing is critical, as you must ensure that the limitation of actions has not passed. Under s5(1AAA) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1958 (Vic), an action must be brought within one year of the alleged defamatory material being published.
The Elements of Defamation:
For a claim of defamation to be successful, certain elements or circumstances must be met. These elements largely follow from past cases but is set out in the Act. The elements are as follows:
- There must be a ‘publication’: The alleged defamation must be published or conveyed to one or more people or parties other than the plaintiff/claimant. Here, the scope is extremely wide. Defamatory ‘publications’ have been held to include oral conversations, as well as informal publications such as social media comments and posts. For example, in Mickle v Farley [2013] NSWDC 295, a former student was successfully sued for defamatory comments made about a teacher on Twitter.
- Identification: The alleged defamatory material must identify the claimant. The identification of the claimant need not be by name but must be such that an average person would be able to identify them. For example, ‘the CEO of X Company’ is identifiable.
- Statement must be defamatory: The publication of alleged defamatory material must actually lower the reputation of the claimant. This is tested from the perspective of an ordinary reader within the context of the publication.
- ‘Serious harm’ caused: Parliament has since upped the threshold for claims to succeed through the introduction of the ‘serious harm’ threshold in s10A of the Defamation Act. The judge will be responsible for assessing and making this determination of whether ‘serious harm’ has been met.
Circumstances for Corporations:
For the most part, corporations are precluded from being eligible to sue unless, pursuant to s9 of the Defamation Act, they are an ‘excluded corporation.’ An excluded corporation is one that is either a non-profit corporation or one that employs less than 10 people.
Defences:
The defences for defamation are set out in Division 2 of the Defamation Act Vic, however, defences founded in past cases still operate. The main defences are as follows:
- S26, the defendant can prove what they posted was substantially true: The Court will focus on the contextual imputations made. There is little prospect of success for a claimant if the overall publication contains substantially true allegations, even if they contain the presence of some false statements.
- S31, the defendant was offering honest opinion as opposed to making a statement of act: This defence may acquit a defendant where they made a mere statement of opinion, so long as this opinion was made based on ‘proper material’.
Operation of the Matter:
Before pursuing litigation, it is important to note the stance of Parliament and the Courts is against frivolous disputes. Division 3 of the Defamation Act sets out the way a matter should proceed and the importance of alternative dispute resolution prior to the Court’s involvement. Specifically, under s12B of the Act, a concerns notice must be issued detailing the alleged contravention of law prior to proceedings being commenced.
Conclusion:
Whether you believe your reputation has been harmed or you’ve been accused of making a defamatory statement, understanding your rights is the first step toward resolving the issue.
At Regal Lawyers, we assist both plaintiffs and defendants with clear, strategic advice tailored to your circumstances. If you’re facing a defamation issue, book a consultation with our team, we’re here to help you navigate the process with confidence.
